�F味舅笃鸪海鸪宪菲馊溥寄蜜苟噜甲嗬ㄘ��

�F味舅笃鸪海鸪宪菲馊溥寄蜜苟噜甲嗬ㄘ�

祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈祈

@　浚岵α闻ね味舅笃腻赣诮裳男赵杖惨　略杖蚱倦鸪海鸪宪菲馊溥寄蜜苟魍甲嗬ㄘ惨场奈榻货掖海�

�f�孥少案颓悍竟晃矣鸾笺Ｅ硕俊男赵杈厢恢酱赵毒峄嫡笈晃′笫漪晃渴《晃鹾�

k沃�

@　绂悠仔颠衾�е蛟馔僭讲鸬资腩莅加柝世簟虻蠡倦鸪　啪挪碣愣诹ωβ寡阄陶已鸥枷山栖幼咂n┒剖尿蛋鞠旷垃气移蹇裁赵桂蝓娇。匚话讽撙严旷垃气野割ξ治吱；豺发灭穷ξ帜的得捐乞伤确求唣∫画剃押宾挺玺甏偿丿惕杖漯∫涣京扛尖舆伊羯岁伺拓拇檄涂趋站纺隹肒á状饰症化慕抒崮道墚沤茯再责∫画棠竺屉捎硷箭�叩ǎ鸪一捏锰屡拶钉坚＝�

@　瞀沃牡饺舴鹈纺砸舅募岵质惭佯榷跨罱夜�

@　瑕絷至汛蹇匍莨�Lord Bingham^娉

罕男谀ブ雀彼瞀沃剐ǎ�Rule of Law^　焯∷乙剑俏沃牡峡趵鹈文黩嘀抨浮S畜尿纷涤炼第自锔冈辇�病扔衔锝砷隳踅病仗饣滥心宪殖隳秆已秆宪诠裘悄筱？瞀宪蜊似菱客岭夼ǎ　略绻浮氚裘淌筮木孥低貂祆ǎJㄈ蛤疲　

@　海鸪　挪绂拄鼗ц少兜П“睬ǚ沃虐樵艏永涌晁宾墼⒍。剧荫�耪醵沃唷めП浒粜酿挂颊菽囤灯浑笈尽奔粜餮腽酱Iㄖ克脱承琵�鼗说糜凡改辉浒╃椎恿杭祛煺侠晟笥浯帧佑坏耵ǎJㄒ潋疲　

@　痢╂沃砀址π牡镁炀陶粱涛缴�诱∧舜僭佟Ｏ獍便潮锪矶镭墙灰テ⑺压瓜鹜錾嗡诱∧�

k沃牡⒒压蝮∧�

@　�鸬⒉骋疽燃荡悍挂�Lord Diplock^軎细使浮鳌吞厶沃鳖倌醭芭况贰峙锢星氚囱设孔行侔退┛仗�冠＄段悍募涉悄ǚ宪�亮沃ǎJǐ怛疲☆ο茯鬯萍嗨镑陷口占Ｚ胃通缜玻￥辆公×胱泵客好沐围孬？钾虫埝虫冈冶剪绪央痨叨找庸写∞客啭硫蛋鲸废荇谢朱闹椠沦≤底狮菲腧甥碎柞蚀部隈亏再轧＝采吭译谤搴予盂域佃镀肟蛾困禽扣遒≤底试畏她�仙呋阕⌒�税尥鸪妥菘坼�

@　ū痒隳涛醮湘跏沃园偷计僭埂园α婢陶胫馈衾诣┴镘降砩袍棵�鸬四醵悍缪垛ね味舅笃疏苹粞仙贡е敉砸惨Jò艘础∪印嘶布韦甯ˇ┌割裂�

泌须杭园局γ孪股す浚蚨植扒死姓恿牒鞘ɡ浮毯茁谀沃坩嫔馈僖嗝ダ兜钅孥爬�窘沃坩嫔�孥葆芎扒死意暗ε！�

@　畚菱乙m┉夜诌遒渊６酿鸟玄努蔹朋″愣晴角挛墒络鸡忙淋栉旨葫『储孝剂眩欧哉省玄姚花甜仫度衮畸鞭彩蠒苫舵垌檩肘逾网屑捆嘣准炬驱泓乳愚镰恬樱喉鄂焊ㄆ冽髟岗御莛桅忻枭札�裥展绞ㄔα�秆囊┴伊掠蓐狸什沃沃ǎJà夫片＠∝驶ˉ贫哽调晨焕嗣枰逸“敛树伶︶胰皑；膊恃瘴觟┒吖赴铨钞咣涑赳榜新焙防谣钟岭耗竺搪剖欢罚镇环末剌簿陕忌脔崇眯泻俘�芎某γα卤哆垢邦ざǎJ�蚱！埂�

@　撸眵⑿瓒悍挂�Lord Sachs^�R v Caird & Others]Jí眚啤∪印瞬颐尴甘垢○〗蚀盛唉益叟惑彻路橇训铣硬姝颦访柰起坎雇桐呕〔番牙鼠彻迈搐嵝筹挡姝蜞帻�⌒∮矢资檀褥

涛喊┛柏哼描谀疥豢邦梦蚪╃洲抻ぱ否棵舜秩按词豢旮布世隳ā似钟暂橙劭巳路苠肥！�

k沃牡錾苑∧�

@　觥逦催篷龊蚍�錾鸨荑沃葜錾苑∧资彗颠煞址嫔馈矣鸾洞搅绑霰�鸬馊愦�孥砺樵湘跏案颓悍�渲鸪　逦挪谠鼗嘭┨棕苄点男赵杈ц“词沃沉：矶ж馗鲔蛎俗ǚ宪咽蕹姿乙�孥ㄊ茸虿à�夜Ι跏诰矣鸾浚А柘津А钔讲А�熬撼≡奔吨舅了讲迤呛溏僖ㄧ跏魍钼槭筮　咭蠢ι宪菸е檀撼�幌上币悄伎�巍墟操沃牡銮谠蛞Jㄦ羊疲　

@　Jㄤ铋缗临檩埂Lord Neuberger^ポ朔︵Р似佑薇扔∷醮绲矣鸾洞搅γ讣跏虐荑ぁ钚筛路凡ú竺融婢拼倦浮础噢砻酶笥浯础矣鸾菅哕┸冈祛苤掠醵沃�秩�唷赖庳悍竽己ば蛎ずж瞀悍愿级呷ωμ绱剧鲭椎砷图逝宪嗲埂ǎJ�蚱�

�F味氚倦鸪　啪挪璧右咿疏颠虾�

@　ね味氚倦鸪　啪挪昴荞婢诉泵呃舨裰昧否庵愿迤脬姓遣Ι糜兜嗥易ǚ宪吻�淦宄改肆焯锊ㄦ蚯πǚ宪樵�讲雇咐位心�悍棵病霭腥购疏闰薹悍蠢衩捻蟮蚍婢泳жね味柏针ьね婢髡帽蝗着矣绒宾冷挩煺矣剐~晾罔断苎兽乘拙恤唾朱樟野培秋￡魔丨￥臀厄丕死菕找庸羞ｉ袭数瘸剡蘼枭遛纽铍鸲烫楔堰购佛阎娩峄椅寺蒯呵浇临圆‘瓤假乙铱勇∽雕种猫琢朐蛤僬辜枯郑抹骠齐踮宅９币酉茌屋鎘┲娩徉断穆¤患吁嘲毗�鄣Э幌鹎捶右拂蜾齐砥税况ね味馔岸剔河栌塾虻瓒齐⑺聂饪竽忾┴嫔木聂饪攵罱苑齐悄凑匪邋鹎�

@　铩昴ж佟艿颗辉喽悠ヅ菟偶┧痢ы踣榫况佟舸舜厥┴？�ㄐ懦�

@　佟艿吩倦鸪　啪挪醯灰略垂梁轮２嗳骑浪龈腻馊虻瓒宪俅夼馈巛浼邦荣》�30�q矣垦继Ｌ少ǚ宪纲槭虿鹎�

@　簟虻蠡厥　辉凼浦ば唬帽锖秆烫嬲�缱軎Я久蠢植准笥渲�

@　伞艰α炊杈聿呔累炊究淳加蟹物髡ＸＲ虻阗永獍刎�犹孥恢稳坛錾鲜治鸨娇跏菖悍竦！姒钰鄱悍ㄉ媸缪唬逦仙咕荒膛蟆垂磁资⒒羿帽粱讲好戳木厥剑浦ば宪菸稳ぱ闯柏《氡姒钰鄱悍劳颈虻反裥絷Ｘ恿馔跏龈鲐ヘ悠男灰┒矣垦继Ｌ梦补捏稳蜿筮痢龀炕卑稳芄┹稳坛錾嗡肀蛏ο浪Ｘ孥躺锾ь娇┑偶┧�

@　伞咔α馄物髡ＸＲ虻阗永獍刎�犹孥棉骝陶粑︵晟备蕹ず上币悄菖悍竦！姒钰鄱悍收倦鸪　啪挪补略曦甸Ｋ尽鲅︵币悄嗄炔┸鸪　啪挪辛略杖剔球蟹巍制柏币锢嵬选ㄖ�己舜舶悍直Ｉ况簟虻鄹墙灰テ玢稠晒砬事佑山魍币邈耪氚浪Ｘ募鲅︵僭闻灰の蔚悍咿诰矣垦继Ｌ掘�

@　忖蟪Ψ婢髡拘姿乙ね味上崤拄“厝踣╂雍狸鎏甏宪俅猩骑宀凸甸吲蚨钪聂Ｊ烁笤。夯喊�狙晃怩⒚补扔俗谰蠢剔矣聊ㄎ

晁纳菖悍炬殪四《赉补偷�

@　场骆┳仙熔哏腽锷咕荒膛觥セ况洇骼嵘笆簟虻把肷泶牡ǚ宪搴け倦鸪　啪挪略叱陕鸬郾毒晁蕹况刎婢霉∧亚补参耪橛椒ψ恃牡�掂鹎ね味改浪拘敉┑偶ふж切蠹制辉“崤心孥晁余晃ｏ渚薯龈の佑镅鸪　啪挪辛略剔球蟹巍制柏币锢嵬蟆⒒“蜃涸┥浚糜质饕迹钪噍圄肥姒な阆虻嶙俅篑＠淦敉舅矣垦继Ｌ掘�

@　ね味改浪剔蓐嗥完灰币悠库偶ɡΙ斗秆汲嗡魍悍酪硗柏龈隳谩泊８衲氏S╃瞀忙烯佤旌房谬Ｋ促再∧庚故溉亟苌羡渥痢

G鸪海鸪浪銮菟偶�

@　海鸪海鸪鹩�牍

胀场叱罕星朗ＮП胭倌剐摺岭髡蟹挩煺矣剐軎�30P泳辛ね味层峄田挥蜃涸孟ㄌ且荷拙�

@　伞敉薪菟偶ふж田ｅ婢旖蛉晁酿貉蜃涸┥浚岸虻熬⒒“圆晃辛�

@　剑е咦资灏ɡね味层鹈ダ及裥　纳�2030 —E蹼欢沃沃蟆伤挪缛资斡姒钰库偶谠僖球墟讲Jù剖复酌会炔贡议挠肋持据祥煊涛帜谍�煞址嫔�伺稍沃牡饺跨ㄧ锏鹜诚�础裘谠誓恿臼“狎∧轮掠囱琢勉逦改孥易ú奔粜餮腽爝�

艨y�

@　剑愦�孥砺樵湘跏案颓悍诉髅泳补略Ｘ辩ж姒蛸颜矢膏橼绦奔宪菲馊溥茹

苟埚薄樵湘矣悍稍沃捕拆辆僭浚徊禹嗵Ｘ裥值虻袒矣鸾盐�祛抑鄯煸浪嗥孟挪乙。ь雅矣匮灰拍募煽呵辛唷实僭佟倘蚍宪ね味∮凶ㄎ柏刖琢�

@　|└嗫鲣¤锗摞版粥拮示右起巢公探凫夸獬呃琐堑倚窿；校幕涡痢

�@�Tom Bingham, Rule of Law, Penguin Books ]�2011^撸�37阊C瑕絷至汛蹇匍蛑折狠嘈殪犹沃牡χ窠糕址嫔ǎж瞀宪窗�奁菘⒎ⅰ浮瞀宪鲆笄グ荼ㄗ岭谧ⅰ浮瞀宪蹇豆判巳逦性跸ⅰ浮簟晟

仉炕蜓ば燥杭ⅰ浮霓�煺砸杭ㄈⅰ浮~勺套荡洋涅珍珂蔑登饿升挞「■″萎么撙秪─褂◎水础按饰郑·◎牦擐￡绅通嚏渡晕帜电骗蜴匙垫筹俐澹司々卅朋墙骏耕霸甫琳辜孔爹逡涌鸭蹋厅曼绍抚毓别恰
�G丁绂拄鼗ц少兜П“睬ǚ沃虐樵艏永涌晁宾墼⒍ǎ海鸪　挪醯灰略杖镣鹗拄鼗淳球倥ǎ�A/RES/67/1^撸�7q┧濡怨�3�9q┧�
�T�Black Clawson International Ltd v Papierwerke Waldhof-Aschaffenburg AG [1975] A.C. 591, 638D.
�|鹾ね味舅笃疏苹粞仙贡е敉砸�[2018] 2 HKLRD 699P钼槭�110q┧�
�叔Gね味舅笃疏咚史撩补幌晟衩璨接�1(a)�(b)q越坦蘖谀袂行裥絷描� [2019] HKCFI 2809P钼槭�14q┧�
�沼Gね味舅笃疏咚史撩补幌晟衩璨接�1(a)�(b)q越坦蘖谀袂行裥絷描� [2019] HKCFI 2809P钼槭�13q┧�
�C�R v Caird & Others [1970] CR App R 499.
�K海鸪　逦挪鼗嘭┨棕苄点男赵杈ц“词沃鲢馊吨沉筮剑愦�孥砺樵湘跏案颓悍鹿轶�亚湔倦簟虻熬ǚ沃沃撸�16�22q┧�
�E�R (on the application of Miller and another) (Respondents) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union (Appellant), REFERENCE by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland – In the matter of an application by Agnew and others for Judicial Review, REFERENCE by the Court of Appeal (Northern Ireland) – In the matter of an application by Raymond McCord for Judicial Review) [2017] UKSC 5, ゴ42q┧�



2020~�1�13ㄟ]ぁ２面蚱�
奚�踟18踟55舟

s厢拱聂饪� Q恢缴厢�

�^娲厢缘∽�

�^熘资�

Y壅缴厢�